Read the original article here.

---

The Punched Card: A Lost Innovation That Shaped the Digital Age

While seemingly archaic in our modern digital landscape, the punched card stands as a pivotal, yet often overlooked, innovation that profoundly shaped the trajectory of data processing, automation, and ultimately, the computer revolution. Long before magnetic storage, hard drives, or even the personal computer, punched cards were the primary medium for storing and processing information, acting as the data backbone of businesses, governments, and early computing systems for nearly a century. Understanding punched cards is crucial to appreciating the foundations upon which today's technology is built and recognizing the ingenuity of early pioneers who envisioned digital information storage long before the electronic era. This resource will delve into the history, technology, and lasting impact of punched cards, highlighting their role as a "lost innovation" that was remarkably ahead of its time.

Punched Card: A stiff paper-based medium used to store digital information by representing data through the presence or absence of holes in predefined positions. These holes are mechanically read to interpret the stored information.

A History of Holes: From Looms to Logic

The concept of using punched holes to control machinery and store information wasn't a sudden invention but rather an evolution of ideas spanning centuries. The story of the punched card is a testament to how innovations often build upon previous discoveries, adapting and refining existing concepts to solve new challenges.

Precursors to the Digital Revolution

The roots of the punched card can be traced back to the textile industry, centuries before the advent of computers.

• Early Loom Control (18th Century): The earliest examples of punched hole technology were developed in France for automating weaving looms.

  • Basile Bouchon (1725): Introduced the idea of controlling a loom using punched holes in paper tape. This was a significant step towards automation, but still required manual operation.
  • Jean-Baptiste Falcon & Jacques Vaucanson: Improved Bouchon's design, refining the control mechanism but still requiring human assistance.
  • Context: These early inventions, while not directly related to computing as we know it, established the fundamental principle of using patterns of holes to represent instructions for a machine. This concept of "programming" a machine through physical media was revolutionary for its time.

• The Jacquard Loom (1804): Joseph Marie Jacquard perfected the use of punched cards for loom automation.

  • Automation through Card Chains: Jacquard's loom utilized a chain of interconnected punched cards. Each card dictated the complex patterns woven by controlling the warp (vertical threads) and weft (horizontal threads) of the fabric for a single pass of the shuttle.
  • Significance: The Jacquard Loom is a landmark invention. It demonstrated the power of punched cards to store complex, changeable programs and automate intricate processes. It directly inspired later inventors in the field of data processing. The idea of a "program" being separate from the machine itself, and easily changeable by swapping card decks, was a crucial conceptual leap.

• Information Storage and Retrieval (1832): Semyon Korsakov, a Russian official, explored punched cards for information management.

  • Informatics Pioneer: Korsakov is credited as one of the first to propose punched cards for storing and searching information, predating even Babbage's work in computing.
  • Context: While Korsakov's work is less known, it highlights the parallel evolution of the punched card idea, not just for automation, but also for information management – a crucial aspect of its future in computing.

• Babbage's "Number Cards" (19th Century): Charles Babbage, the visionary behind the Analytical Engine, conceived of using punched cards for data input.

  • Calculating Engine's Store: Babbage envisioned "Number Cards" for his Analytical Engine, designed to store numerical data. These cards, "pierced with certain holes," would interact with levers to input numbers into the engine's memory ("Store").
  • Limitations: Babbage's Analytical Engine remained unbuilt in his lifetime due to technological limitations. However, his theoretical design, including the use of punched cards for data input, was remarkably prescient.

• Musical Automation (1880s): Jules Carpentier developed a system for recording and playing music using punched cards.

  • Mélographe Répétiteur: Carpentier's system consisted of two parts: the Melograph which recorded musical performances onto punched cards and the Melotrope which played back the music from the cards.
  • "Jacquard's Language" for Music: Carpentier explicitly drew a parallel to Jacquard's loom, describing his system as "writing down ordinary music played on the keyboard dans le langage de Jacquard," emphasizing the shared principle of punched hole control.
  • Example: Think of this as an early form of digital music storage, predating piano rolls and other mechanical music players. It demonstrates the versatility of punched cards beyond just textile patterns or numerical data.

The 20th Century: Punched Cards Take Center Stage

The 20th century witnessed the true ascendancy of punched cards, transforming them from specialized tools into a ubiquitous technology that underpinned modern data processing.

• Herman Hollerith and the 1890 US Census: Herman Hollerith is considered the father of modern punched card data processing.

  • Inspired by Looms and Railroad Tickets: Hollerith drew inspiration from both Jacquard looms and "punch photographs" used by railroad conductors to prevent ticket fraud. He envisioned a system to record and tabulate the vast amounts of data from the US Census.
  • Punch Photographs Explained:

  Punch Photographs: A system used by railroad conductors to quickly mark tickets with descriptive information about the ticket holder (e.g., hair color, height) using punches. This helped reduce ticket fraud by allowing conductors to verify the ticket against the passenger's description.

  • Hollerith's Tabulating Machines: Hollerith developed electromechanical tabulating machines that could read and summarize data stored on punched cards. This system dramatically sped up the 1890 census processing, which would have otherwise taken years.
  • Early Applications: Initially, Hollerith's machines simply counted holes. By the 1920s, they evolved to perform basic arithmetic operations, expanding their utility in data processing.

• The Rise of IBM and the Punched Card Industry: Hollerith's Tabulating Machine Company evolved into a dominant force in the data processing industry.

  • Formation of IBM: Hollerith's company merged with others to form the Computing-Tabulating-Recording Company (CTR) in 1911, which was later renamed International Business Machines Corporation (IBM) in 1924. IBM would become synonymous with punched card technology.
  • Competition and Growth: Other companies like Remington Rand, Powers Accounting Machine Company, and Bull also entered the punched card market, contributing to its widespread adoption.
  • Unit Record Machines and Data Processing Systems: These companies manufactured a range of "unit record machines" – specialized electromechanical devices designed to work with punched cards. These machines were combined into data processing systems to automate tasks like sorting, tabulating, and reporting on data stored on card decks.

  Unit Record Machines: Electromechanical machines designed to process data stored on punched cards. These included keypunches, sorters, collators, tabulators, and interpreters, each performing a specific function in data processing workflows.

• IBM's Dominance and the 80-Column Standard: IBM's innovations and business practices solidified their leadership in the punched card industry.

  • The 80-Column Card: In 1928, IBM introduced the 80-column punched card format. This became the industry standard, offering significantly more data storage compared to earlier formats.
  • Business Model and Antitrust Issues: IBM and Remington Rand initially tied punched card sales to machine leases. This practice was challenged by the US government under the Clayton Antitrust Act, leading to a Supreme Court ruling in 1936 that IBM could only set card specifications but not mandate their purchase.
  • Mass Production: By 1937, IBM's production was staggering, producing millions of cards daily to meet the growing demand. Punched cards became essential for business operations, government record-keeping, and even legal documents.

• Punched Cards in World War II: Punched card technology played a surprising role in wartime efforts.

  • Decryption Efforts: Allied forces, including those at Bletchley Park, used punched card equipment to assist in decrypting Axis communications. The sheer volume of cards processed (millions per week) highlights the scale of these operations.
  • Nazi Germany and Censuses: Tragically, punched cards were also used by Nazi Germany for census taking and other purposes, including, controversially, tracking and managing populations during the Holocaust (a topic explored in "IBM and the Holocaust").

• Ubiquity and Cultural Impact Post-War: After World War II, punched cards became deeply ingrained in business and government operations.

  • "Do Not Fold, Spindle or Mutilate": This iconic warning, printed on many punched cards, became a catchphrase of the era, reflecting the importance and fragility of these data carriers.
  • Cultural Symbol: Punched cards became a symbol of the "system," bureaucracy, and the growing influence of technology in everyday life, sometimes viewed both with fascination and a sense of alienation.

• Decline and Obsolescence: The rise of magnetic storage in the 1960s gradually began to displace punched cards.

  • Magnetic Tape and Disks: Magnetic tape offered significantly higher storage capacity and faster access speeds, making it a more efficient medium for data storage and processing. Floppy disks followed, offering even greater convenience and portability.
  • Interactive Terminals: The development of affordable interactive terminals and minicomputers in the mid-1980s finally made punched cards largely obsolete for data and program input.
  • Legacy and Lasting Influence: Despite their obsolescence as a primary storage medium, punched cards left an enduring legacy. The 80-column format persisted in terminal displays and software design, and many data processing concepts developed for punched cards continue to influence modern computing. Even today, some voting machines still utilize punched cards, demonstrating their surprisingly long lifespan in specific niches.

Nomenclature: Speaking the Language of Cards

Understanding punched cards requires familiarity with specific terminology that developed around their use and processing.

• Common Terms:

  • Punched card, punch card, punchcard: All variations were used interchangeably.
  • IBM card, Hollerith card: Terms referencing the dominant manufacturer and the inventor.
  • 80-column card, 90-column card, etc.: Specific formats defined by the number of columns.
  • Card deck: A sequence of punched cards processed together.
  • Chad (or chips): The small pieces of paper punched out to create holes.

• Data Organization:

  • Field: A set of consecutive columns on a card allocated for a specific type of data (e.g., name field, address field). This is analogous to a database field today.
  • Master card: The first card in a group, containing key information for the subsequent "detail cards." Similar to a header record in modern data files.
  • Detail cards: Cards following a master card, containing specific data related to the master card's information.

Formats: A Diversity of Designs

Punched cards came in various formats, each designed for specific purposes and often associated with particular manufacturers.

Hollerith's Early Card Designs

• Early Census Cards: Hollerith's initial cards for the 1890 census were blank and used round holes.
• Printed Templates and Reading Boards: Later cards included printed templates to guide punching and reading. Reading boards were used for manual interpretation of hole positions.
• Card Size Evolution: The initial 3x5.5 inch size evolved to 3.25 x 7.375 inches (83 x 187 mm), matching the size of contemporary US paper currency. This standardization was partly driven by the need for readily available storage solutions (like bank vaults) for the massive volume of census cards.
• Ad Hoc Coding Systems: Hollerith initially used application-specific coding systems, where hole combinations represented different attributes (e.g., sex, marital status).
• Tabulating Machine Counters: Early tabulating machines used counters that could be assigned to specific holes or combinations of holes, enabling the counting and summarization of data.
• 45-Column Card: Later Hollerith designs introduced a 45-column card with ten rows (0-9), allowing for the representation of multi-digit numbers and enabling arithmetic operations beyond simple counting.

IBM 80-Column Format: The Industry Standard

The IBM 80-column card became the dominant format, shaping the industry for decades.

• Rectangular Holes and Increased Capacity: Introduced in 1928, the 80-column card used rectangular holes, allowing for denser data packing and nearly doubling the capacity compared to earlier formats.

• Dimensions and Materials: Standard size of 3.25 x 7.375 inches (83 x 187 mm), made of smooth card stock 0.007 inches (180 μm) thick.

• Corner Cuts: Diagonal corner cuts were used for card orientation and separation (e.g., master cards vs. detail cards).

• Character Encoding:

  • Zone and Digit Punches: The 80-column card used a combination of "zone punches" (rows 12, 11, 0) and "digit punches" (rows 0-9) to represent alphanumeric characters and special symbols.
  • Decimal Data and Overpunching: Decimal numbers used digit punches. Signs (+/-) were indicated by "overpunching" the rightmost column with a zone punch.
  • Alphabetic and Special Characters: Letters and special characters were encoded using combinations of zone and digit punches. IBM introduced upper-case letters and special characters in 1931.
  • EBCDIC and Hollerith Card Code: Later encoding schemes like EBCDIC increased complexity, and the "Hollerith Punched Card Code" (ANSI standard) aimed to standardize character representation.

  Zone Punching Positions: The top three rows (12, 11, and 0) of an 80-column punched card. These rows were used in combination with digit punches to represent alphabetic characters and special symbols.

  Digit Punching Positions: The lower ten rows (0 through 9) of an 80-column punched card. These rows were primarily used to represent numeric digits.

  Overpunching: Adding a zone punch to a column that already contains a digit punch. This was used, for example, to represent signs (+/-) in numeric fields.

• Binary Formats: For computer applications, "binary formats" were used where each hole represented a single bit of data, maximizing storage density. This was common in early computers like the IBM 701 and 704.

  • Column Binary and Row Binary: Different binary encoding schemes existed, such as "column binary" and "row binary," optimizing data access for specific computer architectures.
  • Example: FORTRAN Cards: In FORTRAN programming, columns 1-72 were typically used for code, and columns 73-80 for sequential card numbering. This numbering allowed for machine sorting to restore card deck order if dropped.

• Human-Readable Printing: Keypunch machines like the IBM 026, 029, and 129 could print human-readable characters along the top of the card, making them easier for humans to interpret and verify.

• Lace Cards: As a prank, "lace cards" were created by punching holes in every possible position. These cards were structurally weak and prone to jamming machines, highlighting the delicate balance between data density and physical integrity.

• IBM 5081 Card Format: A common general-purpose 80-column layout without pre-defined fields, often used as a standard blank card.

IBM Stub Card and Short Card Formats

• Stub Cards: Long cards with a scored section (stub) that could be torn off, leaving a standard 80-column card. Stub cards themselves were also used for applications requiring tags or labels.
• Short Cards: 80-column cards scored at both ends, creating both a stub card and a "short card" when torn. Short cards were compatible with specific IBM machines and formats.

IBM 40-Column Port-A-Punch Card Format

• Manual Punching for On-the-Spot Recording: The Port-A-Punch, introduced in 1958, was a manually operated punch device for creating 40-column cards in the field.
• Pocket-Sized Convenience: Designed to be portable, it enabled "on-the-spot" data recording for tasks like inventory, job tickets, and surveys, eliminating the need for pre-written documents.

IBM 96-Column Format

• Smaller Round Holes and Higher Density: Introduced with the IBM System/3 in 1969, the 96-column card used smaller round holes and a more compact format to increase data density.
• 6-bit BCD and 8-bit EBCDIC Encoding: Stored data in 6-bit Binary Coded Decimal (BCD) or 8-bit Extended Binary Coded Decimal Interchange Code (EBCDIC), organized in three tiers of 32 characters each.
• Limited Adoption: The 96-column format was primarily used within IBM's System/3 and did not achieve widespread adoption outside of this system.
• Recycled Mechanism: Surprisingly, the 96-column card mechanism was later repurposed in IBM 3624 ATMs as receipt printers.

Powers/Remington Rand/UNIVAC 90-Column Format

• Dual-Character Columns: Remington Rand's 90-column card format, evolving from earlier Hollerith designs, achieved higher density by encoding two characters in each of its 45 columns.
• Two Sets of Rows: Used two sets of six rows per card, labeled 0, 1/2, 3/4, 5/6, 7/8, and 9. Combinations of punches within these rows represented characters.

Powers-Samas Formats

• Variety of Formats: The British Powers-Samas company used a diverse range of card formats, including 45, 36, 40, 65, and even 130-column cards. They also offered a 21-column stub card.
• 130-Column Card: Their 130-column card was achieved by dividing the card into two rows, each with 65 columns, further increasing data density.

Mark Sense Format

• Electrographic Pencils and Pre-Punched Cards: Mark sense cards, developed by Reynold B. Johnson at IBM, allowed for data to be entered by marking pre-printed ovals with a special electrographic pencil.
• Combined Manual and Machine Input: Cards were typically pre-punched with fixed information. Variable data was then marked on the ovals and later punched into the card by a card punch with mark sense reading capabilities.
• Use Case: Inventory Management: Commonly used for inventory, where item details were pre-punched, and quantities on hand were marked manually.

Aperture Format

• Microfilm Integration: Aperture cards combined punched card technology with microfilm. They featured a cut-out section to mount a 35mm microfilm image, typically containing engineering drawings.
• Engineering Drawings and Documentation: Used extensively for managing engineering drawings, with drawing numbers and related information punched and printed on the card.

Manufacturing: The Engine of Card Production

The mass production of punched cards was a significant industrial undertaking.

• Rotary Presses and High-Speed Production: IBM's Fred M. Carroll developed high-speed rotary presses that revolutionized card manufacturing. His 1936 model could produce 850 cards per minute.
• Carroll's Press and IBM's Profitability: Carroll's high-speed presses were incredibly efficient and contributed significantly to IBM's profitability during the mid-20th century.
• Printing Plates as Artifacts: Discarded printing plates from card presses, each cylinder-shaped plate corresponding to a specific card layout, became collectible IBM artifacts, sometimes repurposed as desk accessories.
• Cost of Cards: In the mid-1930s, a box of 1,000 cards cost approximately $1.05 (equivalent to around $24 in 2024), highlighting their relatively low cost and widespread affordability.

Cultural Impact: Holes in Our Memory

Despite their obsolescence, punched cards left a significant cultural footprint, influencing art, architecture, and even language.

• Art and Architecture:

  • Maya Lin's "Input" Installation: Artist Maya Lin designed a public art installation resembling a punched card, reflecting the information age and data representation.
  • University Building Designs: Several university buildings, like Tucker Hall at the University of Missouri and the Engineering Research Building at the University of Wisconsin – Madison, incorporate architectural elements rumored to be inspired by punched card patterns, though sometimes these are apocryphal stories. Gamble Hall at the University of North Dakota explicitly uses bricks to spell out "University of North Dakota" in a punched card-like pattern.

• Symbol of Bureaucracy and Alienation: During the 1960s Free Speech Movement, punched cards became a symbol of impersonal systems and bureaucratic alienation. Students felt reduced to mere data points, like "IBM cards," leading to protests against the "IBM pattern of education."

• Legacy in Computing Conventions:

  • 80-Column Display Standard: The 80-column format of punched cards influenced the design of character-based terminals, with 80 characters per row becoming a common display standard that persists in some contexts even today (e.g., command prompt windows).
  • File Formats: Some file formats, like FITS (Flexible Image Transport System) for astronomical data, still utilize the 80-character card image format.
  • Two-Line Element Sets: The format for tracking objects in Earth orbit is also based on punched card conventions.

• Popular Culture References:

  • Arthur C. Clarke's "Rescue Party": Science fiction author Arthur C. Clarke, writing in 1946, imagined alien explorers discovering a vast archive of punched cards containing data on humanity.
  • Lily Tomlin's "I.B.M." Comedy Routine: Comedian Lily Tomlin's routine satirized the use of punched cards for billing, instructing listeners on how to "shrink" the holes to make them unreadable, reflecting public frustration with automated systems.

"Do Not Fold, Spindle or Mutilate": An Enduring Motto

• Ubiquitous Warning: The phrase "Do Not Fold, Spindle or Mutilate" became synonymous with punched cards, appearing on countless cards intended for public use.
• Cultural Catchphrase and Satire: Coined by Charles A. Phillips, it became a motto of the post-World War II era, widely recognized even by those unfamiliar with "spindling." It was often parodied and satirized, becoming a symbol of the rigid rules and perceived absurdity of the machine age.
• Literary and Film References: The phrase inspired book titles and film titles, further embedding itself in popular culture.

Standards: Defining the Card

Several standards were developed to define the physical characteristics and data encoding of punched cards, ensuring interoperability and data exchange.

• ANSI and ISO Standards: Organizations like ANSI (American National Standards Institute) and ISO (International Organization for Standardization) published standards for punched cards, including:
  • ANSI INCITS 21-1967 (R2002): Specifies rectangular hole dimensions and locations for 12-row punched cards.
  • ANSI X3.11-1990: General specifications for paper cards used in information processing.
  • ANSI X3.26-1980 (R1991): Defines the "Hollerith Punched Card Code" for character encoding.
  • ISO 1681:1973: Specifications for unpunched paper cards.
  • ISO 6586:1980: Defines the implementation of ISO 7-bit and 8-bit character sets on punched cards, ensuring compatibility with existing Hollerith-based systems.

Punched Card Devices: Machines of the Card Era

A variety of specialized machines were developed to create, process, and read punched cards.

• Keypunches: Machines with keyboards used to manually punch data onto cards.
• Unit Record Equipment: A suite of electromechanical machines for processing punched card data, including:
  • Card Sorters: Machines that sorted cards based on hole patterns in specific columns.
  • Tabulating Machines: Machines that counted, summed, and printed reports from data on punched cards.
  • Collators: Machines that merged and matched card decks based on data content.
  • Interpreters: Machines that printed human-readable characters on punched cards based on the hole patterns.
• Computer Punched Card Readers: Input devices for early computers that read programs and data from punched cards. Early readers processed around 100 cards per minute, while "high-speed" readers reached speeds of about 1,000 cards per minute.
• Computer Card Punches: Output devices that punched data onto cards under computer control.
• Voting Machines: Some voting machines continued to use punched cards even into the 21st century, demonstrating the technology's surprising longevity in specific applications.

Conclusion: A Hole in History, a Foundation for the Future

The punched card, though now largely replaced by more advanced technologies, stands as a remarkable "lost innovation" that was undeniably ahead of its time. It served as the bedrock of data processing for much of the 20th century, driving automation, shaping business practices, and even influencing cultural perceptions of technology. By understanding the history and technology of punched cards, we gain a deeper appreciation for the ingenuity of early innovators and the evolutionary path that led to the sophisticated digital world we inhabit today. The legacy of the punched card is not just in the machines it powered, but also in the fundamental concepts of digital representation and automated data processing that it pioneered – concepts that continue to underpin modern computing.